Monday, 9 November 2026

Why 1970s TV Looks Like it Was Made Yesterday

Watching TV programmes made in the early 1970s shot on videotape can be a strange experience. Though the programmes were made more than fifty years ago, the visual experience itself seems almost present-day. It is as if the camera has been transported back to 1972 and is showing us the world as it actually appeared at that moment.

This effect is particularly noticeable in colour TV dramas and drama series that made extensive use of outside-broadcast videotape cameras. Watching colour episodes of the TV series Public Eye, for example, you will see outdoor scenes were the actors walk along  streets, go into and out of buildings and generally interact with their surroundings.

These scenes have an extraordinary immediacy about them, as if we are looking through a window at the world rather than watching a recording of it. What is the reason for this? Why should videotape from the early 1970s feel more visually immediate than modern digital HD video, or even film stock from the same period?

With film stock, light comes through the camera lens and forms a chemical image on the emulsion, and the result has its own particular qualities: grain, contrast and the way it processes colour. Without realising it, we know we are looking at a photograph of something filmed.

Film translates the world into an image, and puts its own photographic stamp on whatever it films. That’s why a drama shot on 16 mm in 1972 looks of its time. We are not just seeing 1972, we are seeing a photographic interpretation of it. 

Unlike film, which records a sequence of individual photographic frames, videotape converts light into an electronic signal and reconstructs the image through a scanning process. 

This results in buildings, streets, pavements, shop windows and interiors seeming to have an extraordinary physical presence. Rather than appearing as elements within a photographic composition, they seem to occupy a continuous three-dimensional space. It is as if the camera has become an additional pair of eyes. In other words, videotape looks like a continuation of seeing, whereas film looks like a representation of seeing. The former brings us into contact with the world itself; the latter presents us with an image of that world.

The most intriguing consequence of this is the way it affects our perception of historical time. When watching a film made in 1972, we are usually conscious of its age: that we are looking at something from another period. But when watching 1970s videotape, this historical distance disappears.

You might expect modern digital HD video cameras to have improved on the immediacy of videotape. In some respects it has, but its visual characteristics are deigned to mimic the look of film. Even news and current-affairs programmes look as if they are filmed. 

Early 1970s videotape doesn't just show us a world that existed fifty years ago; it puts us directly in that world, with all the immediacy of looking around us in the present. The streets, the buildings, the people and the everyday details are not muted by the passage of time. They are there, before our eyes. We know that we are watching a recording of the past, but visually we feel as though the past has somehow become the present. And that is the magic of videotape: it allows us to experience a past time as if it were still here.

History of the Media Studies Department at South Mersey College

From 1989 to 1991, I studied Media Studies at South Mersey College. It was a fantastic course, and those years were among the best of my life. For the past year, I’ve been researching the college’s history, and what follows is what I have found.

South Mersey College was established on 1 September 1986, following a reorganisation of Liverpool's further education service. It was formed by merging two existing institutions, Riversdale College of Technology and Childwall Hall College of Further Education. The idea was to bring together two colleges with quite different traditions and strengths, creating one better placed to meet the changing demands of further education.

Riversdale had a strong technical and vocational tradition, and its history included a spell as a naval training establishment. Its culture was fairly hierarchical, reflecting the backgrounds and outlook of many of its staff. Childwall Hall, by contrast, had built up a strong community ethos and a reputation for opening up education to people who might otherwise have been shut out of further education. It was also the more innovative of the two, having introduced courses in areas such as American Studies, Media Studies and Access to Higher Education.

So the merger was about more than putting two colleges under one management. It meant trying to blend different institutional cultures and approaches to education. John Frain, who became principal of the new college, knew this would take time. In his book about the college's development, The Changing Culture of a College, he explained that management at first favoured a traditional hierarchical structure, believing that organisational change needed to move at a manageable pace. Too much change too quickly risked creating uncertainty and putting unreasonable demands on staff.

In its first few years, though, South Mersey College expanded its curriculum considerably. New courses included Trades Union Studies, Special Needs education and Media Studies, alongside a growing range of adult education, community education and access to university courses. The college also tried out new ways of delivering education, particularly through Open Learning. By 1988/89 it was running an increasingly diverse programme of courses, and management was starting to rethink the organisational structure put in place when the college was formed.

Media Studies was one of the areas that grew out of the more innovative Childwall Hall tradition, and by 1988/89 it was an established part of the college's ecosystem, and was gaining a growing reputation among media organisations on Merseyside. The college had secured an Urban Aid grant of £60,000 to buy Media Studies equipment over three years, and it was also developing a full-time BTEC Diploma in Media Studies. By September 1989, the course was headed by Carol Duerden.

This development did not come without difficulties. The closure of the Childwall campus meant Media Studies had to move to the Riversdale campus. John Frain's book admitted that this had caused problems, though he noted that they were being kept under review.

There were apparently tensions within the department. Some staff complained that it had been hard to get hold of much of the equipment they needed, but these were practical concerns rather than criticisms of how the course was run. They may well have reflected the difficulties of establishing and maintaining a fairly new course in a college going through major organisational change, and they should be seen alongside the wider problems the principal recorded: the relocation of Media Studies, staff shortages, and the pressure to develop new provision while resources remained limited.

This was the background against which Media Studies was operating in September 1989, when I started the course. As a student, I knew nothing of these issues, and my experience of it was a very positive one. I was simply delighted to be there.

Thursday, 5 November 2026

Donovan's Complicated Relationship with Fame

Donovan Leitch was undoubtedly one of the more interesting musicians to emerge from the British folk and psychedelic scene of the 1960s. He wrote good songs, developed a distinctive guitar style and, for a period, moved in very influential musical circles. He was also a friend of the Beatles.

Yet there is something about his public persona that can make listening to him discuss his career an exhausting experience. He appears to see his place in musical history in unusually inflated terms, and his recollections of important moments in popular music sometimes seem intended not merely to describe events but to establish the significance of his own role within them.

Consider his relationship with the Beatles. He was certainly part of their social circle in 1968 when they travelled to India to study meditation with Maharishi Mahesh Yogi. He also taught John Lennon a fingerpicking technique that Lennon later used in songs such as ‘Dear Prudence’ and ‘Julia’; and Paul McCartney has also acknowledged learning fingerpicking techniques from Donovan.

These are genuine contributions to musical history, and he deserves credit for them. Yet his own accounts of that period have often gone substantially further. For example, he has suggested that he played a significant role in guiding the Beatles back towards their musical roots. It is, though, difficult not to raise an eyebrow at such claims, especially as the Beatles were already one of the most innovative and influential musicians of their generation.

In a 2005 Sunday Times interview with Donovan's about his autobiography The Hurdy Gurdy Man, James Walton writes:

'Few have escaped the Hurdy Gurdy Man’s put-downs. Of Bob Dylan, he thinks, “his lyrics are without equal, but I think I am musically the more creative and influential”. On teaching Paul McCartney how to finger pick the guitar he says: “He did not have the application to get it, but he wrote some lovely ballads under the influence of my style.” Jimi Hendrix, apparently, “found I was the nicest person he’d ever met!”'

And Walton goes on to say:

'Professionally, his first hurdle was unfavourable comparisons with Dylan, but the Scot is quick to claim precedence. “My friend Gypsy Dave reminded me last year: ‘I called you up in ’64 and told you there’s this singer/songwriter in America doing just what you’re doing with a harmonica and a cap’.”'

And in a 2013 interview with Bill DeMain in Performing Songwriter, Donovan reiterates his significance as a Dylan-like figure:

'I took on the mantle very early to be a voice for a generation who was speaking out against hypocrisy and greed.'

In a 2005 Guardian interview by Dorian Lynskey, aptly titled ‘No Name Left Undropped’, Donovan's conversational style comes under mild scrutiny, when Lynskey describes long anecdotes in which famous acquaintances frequently appear. Bob Dylan, George Harrison, Paul McCartney, Keith Moon and many more make appearances in the narratives.

There is nothing wrong with this in itself, as he genuinely knew the people he mentions; and any account of his life he makes would naturally include extraordinary people. The question then is not whether these stories are true but how prominently they feature in the way he presents his career.

It is easy to comes away from his interviews with the impression that the associations themselves are being offered as evidence of importance. Thus, the emphasis can seem less focused on the events than on the fact that he was present when they occurred. Ths could make him appear as a sort of musical Forest Gump to some people.

Similarly, in a 2024 review of a Donovan concert at Manchester's Royal Northern College of Music, published by 'Northern Soul', Andy Murray (not the tennis player) praised his musicianship while also noting the lengthy introductions, reminiscences and stories involving the Beatles, the Who and other famous people from the 1960s.

Murray's criticism was not that these stories were in themselves boring, but that the repeated references to significant people were boring. He said, tellingly, that Donovan didn’t need to rely on them, as his own achievements were substantial enough to get attention without constant reminders of his proximity to other famous people.

That is a significant observation. Donovan's catalogue contains enough notable work to justify his place in music history on its own merits. Songs such as ‘Sunshine Superman’, ‘Mellow Yellow’, ‘Atlantis’ and ‘Hurdy Gurdy Man’ ensure that.

His relationship with Bob Dylan provides another example. In the mid-1960s, Donovan was frequently portrayed as Britain's answer to Dylan. Their “encounter” in D. A. Pennebaker's documentary Don't Look Back has become a well-known part of Donovan’s career. Many viewers interpret Donovan in the film as being a musician attempting to win the approval of an already established one. Over the years, he has repeatedly challenged that interpretation.

There is nothing unreasonable about disputing a narrative one believes to be inaccurate. However, listening to these accounts, one sometimes gets the sense that the discussion is as much about historical standing as it is about historical accuracy.

A similar pattern can be seen elsewhere. Donovan has occasionally spoken about friendships and interactions with Paul McCartney, Ringo Starr and George Harrison. Whether discussing the Beatles, Dylan or other notable people, his recollections frequently return to the question of influence, significance and recognition.

Taken individually, none of this is particularly unusual, many artists reflect on the most important periods of their lives and careers. Yet Donovan's interviews sometimes feel less like recollection and more like promotion. He seems engaged in an ongoing attempt to establish exactly where he belongs in the hierarchy of 1960s popular music.

The irony, as noted earlier, is that he hardly needs to make the case, as his contribution to that era was real and significant. He was not just a witness to the cultural revolution of the 1960s but a participant. The odd thing is that the case would probably be stronger if he felt less need to make it.

Tuesday, 3 November 2026

The Remarkable Story of My Ancestor Agnes Birrell


Over the past ten years, my sister has been researching and compiling our family history. In the process, she uncovered the story of a particularly fascinating ancestor whose life took her from Scotland to the American West, and whose descendants would eventually become connected to the famous Osmond family. This is her story.

Agnes Birrell was born on 17 January 1841 in Barony, Lanarkshire, Scotland. She was the oldest daughter of William Birrell and Mary Neil. She had two brothers, William and John, and a sister, Charlotte. Her parents had a young daughter who died before Agnes was born. The family moved frequently as her father worked in the mines.

Her family were Mormons, and as a young girl, she was baptised into the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints on 6 October 1852 in the Irvine Branch in Scotland. The family planned to emigrate to America to join the Mormon community, and as the oldest daughter, Agnes was sent ahead to help prepare for their arrival.

On 11 April 1859, she boarded the ship William Tappscott in Liverpool, England, at the age of eighteen. There were 725 British, Scandinavian, and Swiss Mormons on board, and the voyage lasted thirty-one days.

After arriving in New York, the Mormons sailed on the steamer Isaac Newton up the Hudson River to Albany, then travelled by train to St. Joseph, Missouri. From there, they took the steamboat St Mary to Florence, Nebraska, arriving on 25 May.

It was nearly three weeks before handcarts became available and preparations for the journey west were complete. Under the direction of Captain George Rowley, the company began their trek on 9 June 1859. The group consisted of 235 people, 60 handcarts, and six ox-drawn wagons. Each handcart carried bedding, clothing, and 200 pounds of flour—enough for about a week.

The journey was arduous. They reached Fort Laramie on 27 July, only to discover their food supplies were nearly depleted. By 22 August, at the Green River, swift currents made crossing perilous. Oxen were killed for food, and every part of the carcass was used. Soup was made from willow leaves and knuckle bones. Supplies from Salt Lake City eventually rescued the company on 25 August, but some had already perished.

On 4 September 1859, the company entered Salt Lake City via Emigration Canyon on a Sunday afternoon at about 5 pm. Agnes had walked the entire way across the Plains, pushing a handcart, enduring immense hardship to leave her family, cross the sea, and traverse the desert—all for her faith. Shortly after her arrival, she went to work for William Thomas Van Noy and his wife Catherine.

On 25 December 1859, Agnes became the second wife of William Thomas Van Noy in a plural marriage, sealed by Mormon President Brigham Young in his office. She received her endowments on 11 April 1860. Agnes and William had eleven children together.

The family lived in Salt Lake City until 1864, when a fort was built in Richmond, Utah. They moved into an adobe house inside the fort and were allotted ten acres outside. In 1875, they purchased 160 acres in Riverdale, Idaho, where the Bear River formed a semi-circle around their home. Only four families lived nearby at that time. Their home was plain, with bare wooden floors and unpainted walls.

Agnes and William worked tirelessly to raise their family, producing their own food from their garden and orchard, cultivating sugar cane, and making molasses, and provided their children with an education.

Agnes endured considerable hardship in raising her family. Nine hours after giving birth to her eleventh child, she died on 22 February 1879. Her children remembered her as “their angel mother” and William referred to her as his “angel wife”. William, survived her by over two decades, passing away on 2 March 1900, in Richmond, Cache County, Utah, at the age of 72.

Their descendants continued the family line through several generations. Their son, Thomas Lorenzo Van Noy (1866–1929), married Martha Tyresha Vail (1870–1912) on January 13, 1887, in Logan, Cache County, Utah. Thomas and Martha had a daughter named Florence Edna Van Noy (1891–1973), who went on to marry Joseph Franklin Roberts (1886–1938) on 21 April 1913, in Thayne, Lincoln County, Wyoming. Florence and Joseph raised a family of four children: Mary Vannoy Roberts (1914–1978), Frank Vannoy Roberts (1916–1997), Mathew Vannoy Roberts (1919–1990), and Griffith Vannoy Roberts (1926–1995).

Another central figure in the family was Agnes and William's daughter, Agnes Laverna Van Noy (1892–1986), whose life was marked by three marriages. She first married Rulon Osmond (1893–1917) on October 8, 1913, in Salt Lake City, Utah, with whom she had three sons: Rulon Van Noy Osmond (1914–2001), Ralph Jacobson Osmond (1915–1977) and George Viri Osmond (1917–2007)—who became the father of the Osmond singing family. Following Rulon's passing, she married John Wesley Neyman (1873–1959) on September 2, 1921, and they welcomed a daughter, Cora Elizabeth Neyman. Finally, on August 15, 1932, Agnes Laverna married Clarence Hoopes in Logan, Utah.

Additionally, Agnes and William were parents to Isaac Devon Van Noy (1910–1978). Isaac married Lavon Miriam Edgren (1914–1995) on July 31, 1934, in Paris, Bear Lake County, Idaho, and the couple had two children, Gerald E. Van Noy and Carol Jean Van Noy, both of whom died in childhood.

Agnes Birrell's life lasted less than four decades, but the family she helped establish continued for generations. Her story spans two continents and brings together Scottish mining communities, Mormon emigration, the settlement of the American West and, unexpectedly, one of the best-known entertainment families of the twentieth century.